The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Tuesday, June 16th, 2009




“Tell your stupid story . . . and die already!” – Elaine Benis on the English Patient

Benjamin Button takes you on a long, pointless journey with a passionless void of cliched themes and uninspired screen-writing. So many other critics have labeled this a rip-off of Forrest Gump, but as this film was based on a Fitzgerald work, I guess it would be the other way around, in essence. Either way, comparing this to Forrest Gump is like comparing Throw Momma From the Train with Body Heat – there is no direct comparison. It’s lazy criticism and knee-jerk journalism. Since I caught this after it was released and heard the comparison, I started to dissect that theory, and really, with the exception of it being about a challenged man’s life, there endeth the comparisons.
On its own, Benjamin Button sucked, it was too long and quite boring. It was well acted, or rather it was well animated with some pretty good voice-overs by Brad Pitt as the lead. The whole film I kept waiting for something interesting, something really important, to happen – anything with real dramatic oomph, there were some moments that arguably fit, but nothing that really slammed home. Every chance the film had to be great, it just sort of petered out into nothingness, there were some moments where I felt a crescendo building and then, pianissimo – nothing.  I kept re-writing the script in my head, this is what I would have done here, here is how I would have made this scene more imaginative and lively, for example. Whenever I find myself doing that to a film, it is because I am bored or disgusted. Since I shelled out my own cash for Button, I was both.
I was expecting a lot and was left with the biggest ‘who cares’ ever. Missing from the story was a pivotal antagonist, everyone knows to tell a great story, you need a good antagonist. Benjamin Button had me pining to hit the fast forward button throughout! I like all manner of movies, I like chick flicks and dude flicks equally. My only real criteria for movies is that they keep me interested or entertained at least 90 percent of the time. With Button, I was neither, maybe about 10% of the time I was entertained and for an almost three hour run time, that is just unacceptable.














